His breakthrough came at a tribute concert for a father he'd met exactly once. In 1991, Buckley performed at 'Greetings from Tim Buckley' in Brooklyn, singing a Tim Buckley song written about the infant Jeff and his mother. That gig opened doors in New York music circles, and he built a following with a Monday night residency at Sin-e, a cafe that held fewer than 50 in the East Village. Columbia signed him off those cafe performances. Grace, his debut, reached #149 on the Billboard 200 in 1994. The world caught up after he was gone.
Grace flopped on arrival and became a masterpiece after he drowned. Bob Dylan, David Bowie, and Robert Plant all praised it. His 'Hallelujah' grew into the version most people hear: when Jason Castro covered it on American Idol in 2008, the buzz sent Buckley's original to #1 on iTunes, 14 years after its release. MOJO named Grace the #1 Modern Rock Classic of All Time in 2006. A 2025 documentary, It's Never Over, Jeff Buckley, catalogued all of it. The one album he finished is enough.
He grew up as Scott Moorhead, a name he dropped only after finding 'Jeff Buckley' on his birth certificate. His stepfather Ron Moorhead, not Tim, was the one who handed him his first Led Zeppelin album at 12. In late 1996, he toured the Northeast under rotating aliases: The Crackrobats, Possessed by Elves, Father Demo, Smackrobiotic. He was mortified when People named him one of its 50 Most Beautiful People in 1995. He was last seen in the Wolf River singing 'Whole Lotta Love.'
His body was recovered from the Wolf River six days after the drowning, spotted by a riverboat passenger on June 4, 1997. Columbia released the posthumous double album Sketches for My Sweetheart the Drunk in May 1998, compiled from unfinished sessions. PJ Harvey, Rufus Wainwright, and Chris Cornell each wrote tribute songs. His 'Hallelujah' was inducted into the Library of Congress' National Recording Registry in 2014.