Rise to Fame
No professional headshots, just a camera phone photo. That was the audition packet for Superbad when a 17-year-old with no credits submitted for Fogell. The film grossed over $170 million and the McLovin fake ID became a genuine pop culture artifact. He later said there was a four-year stretch where strangers screamed the name at him constantly, which is a strange way to spend your early twenties.
In the Spotlight
The live-action parts thinned out after Kick-Ass 2, but voice acting absorbed the slack quietly. Fishlegs in How to Train Your Dragon, King Gristle in Trolls, Pigeon Pete in Tales of the TMNT: he's spent the past decade becoming a franchise fixture in animated universes where nobody sees his face. Promising Young Woman (2020) pulled him back into prestige territory briefly. He's working steadily, just not in the way most people are tracking.
Side Notes
His great-grandmother was Margaret Winkler, the Hollywood producer who distributed Felix the Cat shorts in the 1920s, so film runs in the family even if nobody mentions it. His mother was legally required to be on set during his Superbad sex scene because he was 17 at the time, which is a sentence that will never not be funny. He spent his first movie paycheck on a drum kit and eventually ended up playing bass in Ben Kweller's touring band.