Aaron Eckhart

Aaron Eckhart built his career playing the most believable kind of villain, the one who thinks he's the hero. Neil LaBute cast him as the casually cruel protagonist of In the Company of Men in 1997, and suddenly Hollywood had a face for charismatic moral rot. Thank You for Smoking turned that into a Golden Globe nomination in 2006, Eckhart playing a tobacco lobbyist so persuasive you almost rooted for him. Christopher Nolan made Harvey Dent the emotional center of The Dark Knight, and Eckhart carried it. The film made over $1 billion. His career since has been the more interesting question.

After The Dark Knight, the A-list career that should have followed didn't quite materialize. He worked steadily through the 2010s, but the projects rarely matched his ceiling. By the 2020s, he'd fully pivoted to direct-to-video action thrillers, with films like The Bricklayer and Chief of Station getting decent notices but landing on streaming rather than in theaters. It's not a crash, it's more of a drift. He's reliable, watchable, and firmly in the VOD action tier.

He served a two-year LDS mission in France and Switzerland before any Hollywood agent knew his name, which is an unusual setup for a career playing charming sociopaths. He grew up Mormon in Silicon Valley, his family relocating to Surrey, England when he was 13. His early credits include an LDS seminary video called Godly Sorrow. His father threw him out of the house after he pierced his ear with a safety pin.